12 Sep 16

Why are some cheddars orange?

Our Westminster Cheddar is a white cheddar made from the milk of our much-pampered cows! But a question you may have asked when at the grocery story is: why are some cheddars orange?  Here’s all you need to know:

cows cheddar

Cheese is made from milk, which is why our cheddar is known as ‘white’! What a cow eats determines the flavor of the cow’s milk, thus the flavor of the cheese; the natural color also changing according to the diet of the cow. Cows fed on pastures tend to produce milk higher in beta-carotene (the same pigment that gives carrots their lovely bright orange color!) – the more naturally-fed the cow, the darker the cheese, the more flavorsome the taste! This is why our Westminster Cheddar is more of a gorgeous yellow than a pale white; our cows are fed on our beautiful English pastures!

So the darkness of orange cheddar means it’s uber-natural? Not quite – all isn’t what it seems!

westminster cheddar

orange cheddar

Image: Daniel Oines, Flickr

Although it is true that the darker the tone of the cheese the better the diet of the cow, cheese will never naturally be as dark as the bright orange cheddar we see on store shelves, and the reason for this goes way back.

Over 200 years ago, when cheddar first became popular, cheesemakers took advantage of the reputation of darker, yellower cheese by dyeing cheese to make it a bold orange, claiming that the considerably darker color of the cheddar meant it was tastier.

Orange cheddar is cheese dyed with annatto seeds, originating from the annatto tree common in the tropical regions of South America. These seeds are grounded into red powder and used to color cheese; but do not fear, annatto, although a coloring, is completely natural, and in fact has been said to have health benefits including lowering blood pressure and reducing acid.

Now, orange cheddar is loved by cheese-lovers as a bright, attractive addition to a cheeseboard! Choose white cheddar for that authentic look, or orange for a bolder option!

Which do you prefer? Let us know on Facebook or tweet us on @westminsterched!

Sign up to our newsletter for the latest inspiration and giveaways!

Other posts you may like

Non-GMO Sharp Cheddar

Celebrate the launch of our new non-GMO Sharp Cheddar

cheese snacks

13 cheese-loaded Super Bowl snacks!

Cheese Wheels

9 must-know cheese rules to live by!

fruit infused water

Top tips: food inspiration for eating clean!

Westminster Giveaway

Are you a winner of our #GrandmaMakes cheese giveaway? Find out here!

banana frozen yogurt

Healthy snacks for kids: super-nutritious recipes for summertime!

20 wonderfully eye-opening cheddar facts all cheese lovers must know!

15 chutney recipes to truly enhance our tasty Westminster Cheddar!

International beer day

International Beer Day! The Cheese Interviews with Lakefront Brewery!

Bacon Flag Pizza

WOW your guests with mind-blowing cheddar 4th of July recipes!

#GrandmaMakes Competition

#GrandmaMakes – share your well-loved cheesy family recipe for a chance to win a KitchenAid & Westminster Cheddar selection!

cheese board selection

How to create the perfect cheese board this Cheese Lovers Day!

Westminster #DiscoverWestminster Competition

Competition time – Take part in our Twitter competition & #DiscoverWestminster!


Discover daily life on the farm

Westminster Valentine's Competition

Who has #TrueCheeseLove for Westminster Cheddar Cheese? Enter our Valentine’s Day Contest!

zucchini lasagna

5 delightfully healthy cheese recipes!

Halloumi Burger

13 joyous types of cheese & their seductive partners!

Westminster Pinterest

Follow us on Pinterest for AMAZING cheese inspiration!

summer on the farm

Summer on The Farm!

Westminster placeholder thumbnail

Amazing cheese recipes that will ‘WOW’ guests this Easter!

Grilled Corn

Entertaining top tips for Labor Day weekend!

Scandalous Cheesy Snack Pairings

Share your most Scandalous Cheesy Snack Pairing to win!

halloween jalapenos

Super-spooky Halloween recipes with cheese!

Cheese Party

Hosting the ultimate wine and cheese dinner party!

wine and cheese

The Cheese Interviews: wine and cheese pairings with wine blogger Filivino!

It's Not You It's Brie Blog

The most inspirational cheese bloggers around

4th of july competition

The Ultimate All-American Dish Contest! – Vote for your favorite dish to win!

Thanksgiving recipes

#GrandmaMakes Share your Thanksgiving recipes to win!

11 reasons why we adore cheddar!

Cheesy Recipes Competition

Vote For Your Favorite Cheesy Recipe!

orange cheddar

Why are some cheddars orange?

one pot lasagna recipe

23 of the best cheese dishes you’ll ever taste!

Grilled Cheese Contest Winner

Our Grilled Cheese Sandwich Contest Winners! #PinToWin

Grilled Cheese Competition

The Grilled Cheese Competition! #MyGrilledCheeseSandwich

Coopers Hill Cheese Rolling Event

Ancient English cheese traditions: Cheese Rolling on Coopers Hill

Grilled Cheese Sandwich

Cheese Contest Time! – What’s your Favourite Grilled Cheese Recipe? #PintoWIN!


46 mouth-watering types of cheese to inspire you from around the world

Cheese Board

10 top tips for stress free entertaining

Top 10 Scandalous Cheesy Snack Pairings

Top 10 Scandalous Cheesy Snack Pairings To Enjoy This SuperBowl


Coupon Offer – Save $1.00 on your next purchase!

Giveaway time – win our delicious Westminster Cheddar range & a must-have cheese board!

Cauliflower Jalapeno Grilled Cheese Sandwich

#GrandmaMakes memories from foodie blogger – Brooklyn Farm Girl!

Grilled Zucchini and Corn Tostadas

A round up of our favorite foodie bloggers on Pinterest!

gourmet bacon macaroni cheese recipe

13 super-tasty cheddar cheese recipes to try this Spring!